Requiem for writing town

During the pandemic I built a gather town co-working space for my team. The free plan enabled our team to be together even when working from home. Folks claimed their desks, and we co-designed the space to have a garden with flowing water, meeting spaces, private offices, windows with live streams of the outside world, even a piano. Multiple papers were written here, collaborations blossomed, and people found peace and quiet in unassuming copresence. We called it “writing town”; it even had its own URL.

Gather Town 1.0 is no more. On September 15, 2025, there was a forced migration to a more clean and corporate looking 2.0 version. While 1.0 spaces are not deleted outright, the free plan disappeared, making it unavailable for impromptu meetings. The new value proposition —$12/user/month— is not a good deal for us and doesn’t fit the modus operandi we had. So I revisited the space one last time and decided to write something about our experiences. I also asked some of the other users of our space; the post below features also recollections from Iris van Rooij that I quote with permission.

Interactional affordances

While Zoom took off, Microsoft was scrambling to further enshittify Teams, and many companies sprung up in the “3D avatar meeting” space, some of us realized that less is more. When scouting for options for a co-working space, I prioritized interactional affordances over spiffy graphics. What Gather offered was just the right set of features for smooth social interactions. It hit a sweet spot that I still haven’t seen others replicate:

  • a shared sense of space that is distinct from an interaction proper and that provides the anchoring for it (entirely absent in Zoom/Teams/etc.)
  • a simple avatar to signal your presence in the shared space; in line with this, it is customizable within limits but doesn’t aim for detail let alone photorealism
  • an intuitive way to get into and out of interactions, simply by 2D movement to navigate the space (compare this with clicking on a Zoom or Teams invite)
  • being able to see “where the action is” without necessarily immediately jumping in, much in the same way you can check out who’s at the lunch table and then decide to join or not (compare this with plopping into a Teams session: you don’t know who’s there and there’s no graceful exit either )
  • a graded form of co-presence much like in “meat space”: at a distance, you can see each others’ avatars; when coming within a few steps of each other, a little see-through video feed pops up that becomes more solid as you approach each other (and audio likewide fades in an out)

Each of these design features is crucial to the experience, and together, they work to create opportunities for interaction while giving people the agency to navigate where, how, and with whom they interact. Good physical spaces offer these affordances. Somehow when we have to meet virtually, all of this is thrown out the window and we have to make to with all-or-nothing “meetings” that consist of in-your-face video feeds with no sense of shared space and no opportunities for time-out. Gather allowed us to organize our interactions in a much more organic, dynamic, and serendipitous way.

3D is overrated

Staying on the topic of “less is more”, I think Gather also shows that 3D is overrated. Before the Metaverse flopped there was Microsoft Mesh and a ton of other businesses offering 3D avatars. I don’t know who designs these things but I do know they’ve never consulted actual scholars of human interaction. They all make the same basic errors of prioritizing looks and 3D effects over the most basic interactional affordances. Gather did this so much better.

A big benefit of not doing expensive 3D rendering is that you can devote more computational power to making sure video and audio are doing exactly what they need to do, when they need to do it. And since that’s what interaction is all about, especially in a co-working space, that is an excellent design choice. Plus, there is a particular aesthetic to the simple low-res 2D graphics. It’s a representation, a stand-in: it doesn’t need to be photorealistic or even manipulable. It feels great to be able to put a sprite of a comfy chair in my workspace. Why would I need it to be more than 32×32 pixels? I’m not going to sit on it.

It’s always struck me that those pushing 3D spaces for co-working or meetings are making an elementary category mistake. They seem to think interaction is primarily about having a highly detailed facsimile of a 3D world, when really the crucial thing is to create flexible opportunities for interaction. It’s like the difference between Lego blocks (generative, creative, open-ended) and model trains (emulative, literal, closed-off). Just let us play together and do away with the surface realism.

We all grew to love the pixelated 2D look of our virtual offices. People decorated their offices, adding plants, sci-fi computing setups, and chess boards. The courtyard sported some benches with a youtube stream of birdsong. If you peek closely at the screenshot below you might see a duckling in the corridor that escaped from the pond.

screenshot of a 2D gather town environment showing a green courtyard with some trees, benches and a pond, and a number of 'cubicles', working spaces with desks and window views that are customized with different chairs, lamps, and furniture

Gather 1.0 also offered a very simple builder mode with a bunch of graphics, plus the ability to upload your own bitmaps. I remember scouring the web for 2D sprites to add to our office: a globe, a chesterfield sofa, a nice table, a coffee machine. Nothing more is needed. Here again, I felt that Gather hit the sweet spot in terms of features: just an object picker and a cursor for 2D placement, no frills, and it served us well.

A sense of connectedness

It was the height of corona lockdowns and our co-working space soon was bustling with energy. We invited colleagues over and generally welcomed anyone who needed a space to meet. I added a wing for colleagues from Iris van Rooij’s Computational Cognitive Science group. We had post-talk get-togethers, ‘lunch’ meetings with guests from three different time zones, and generally a very good time. As Iris writes:

In a time when no contact was possible in “meat space”  this virtual space really helped to bring a sense of social connectedness during the workday, even when I was working by myself at the table in a corner (see screenshot). I had a whiteboard, a fish bowl, and music, so was very happy there. 

zoomed in screenshot showing an avatar labelled "Iris (she/they)" in an office space with a whiteboard, a desk with a fishbowl on it, an easy chair, and two plants.

Speaking of connectedness, I also think the space made a bunch of collaborations possible. For instance, I remember a lot of visits from Matt Spike and others in the lead-up to this 2021 CogSci paper led by my postdoc Marieke Woensdregt.

Another great feature of the space was that it provided a place to go after bouncing out of yet another Zoom lecture. You click on “Leave meeting” and poof everything’s gone and you’re back to your own devices (literally). But with our co-workers in gather town, we’d often hang out in the common space after a talk, affording us the kind of informal interaction afterwards that really makes it worthwhile to visit talks together.

A room with a view

One design aspect of the space I devoted quite a bit of attention to was windows onto the world outside, both visual and auditory. This was corona, and many of us were stuck at home with few possibilities to be outside or meet others. Our gather office offered a room with a view: several of the office windows opened onto other worlds. For instance, we had a live webcam of the Hoge Veluwe national park and another that featured windowsnap (‘open a window somewhere in the world’). Iris recollects:

Occasionally I would sit in the garden or look out of the window with a view on the Hoge Veluwe park. Sometimes I was lucky to see deer or mouflons there. It would bring joy and calm in my day. At some point there was a chance to update the space with a new window with a view on the basin in Burgers zoo where a baby manatee was (to be) born. Here you can see the little one when it was just born (scroll up and down the thread for full context). 

I had similar experiences. I remember checking out the latest views from the EPIC DSCOVR satellite and seeing it snow on Hoge Veluwe. I also spent a lot of time writing in the courtyard, where among the trees there ran a feed of 3 hours of bird song. I wrote my two chapters for the Oxford Handbook of Lexical Classes in that courtyard (Ideophones; Interjections) and so that work is forever linked to my gather town browser tab and to the sounds of “4K HDR Enchanted Forest”.

Full view of our main co-working space with two "wings" for a total of 14 desks, multiple meeting spaces and a common room (on the carpet) where everyone could meet for lunch or just hang out

So long, writing town

Gather Town 1.0 had a free tier which basically invited us to do a lot of free advertising by bringing along colleagues and co-workers (quite a few of whom decided to build their own space, or organize their conference or workshop in Gather: the Gather conference was a thing in 2020-2022). We were a relatively small team (probably never more than 10 co-workers at a time), but the value proposition was such that we were happy to pay for larger events and even, in one semester, getting our uni to subscribe for longer-term access (e.g. I’ve even given a course in gather in early 2021). I am guessing there weren’t enough customers like us or the free tier was unsustainable somehow. And apparently now there are enough businesses that can easily afford $12 per month per member (not us in academia, unfortunately).

So long and thank you, gather.town 1.0, for facilitating this form of unplanned, flexible copresence. And thank you to all colleagues who hung out with us, stayed around to get work done, helped co-design the space, and in general made sure we all had a good time. Here’s a parting shot of me getting a last coffee, setting on a bench in the courtyard, and waving goodbye.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *